Daily Picks

Inside: The question that sorts real buybacks from press releases.

Every buyback press release reads identically — board authorizes repurchase program — but the machine behind the sentence decides the only thing that matters: when the shares actually disappear. Some programs fire automatically, a set slice of every quarter’s cash. Some are deliberately switched off, then switched back on. And some sit loaded for months, waiting for a markdown.

Over the past ten days, three boards showed us all three designs — roughly $2.2 billion of standing repurchase capacity among them, enough at recent prices to retire about a tenth of one company, an eighth of another, and a twentieth of the third.

Let’s take them one at a time -

Ovintiv Inc. (OVV) — Recent Price: $61.44

Breakdown: Ovintiv — the Denver-based oil and gas producer formerly known as Encana — pumps about 615,000 barrels of oil equivalent a day from two engines: the Permian Basin in Texas and the Montney in western Canada. This year it finished a remodel. It bought Montney producer NuVista for about $2.7 billion last November, sold its Anadarko Basin assets this spring for about $2.8 billion, and used the proceeds to cut net debt nearly in half.

Ovintiv doesn’t buy its stock when it feels inspired; it runs a standing rule — return 50% to 100% of annual free cash flow to shareholders through dividends and buybacks, with at least 60% committed for 2026. The receipts match the rule: under the program this one replaces, it repurchased 13.9 million shares at an average of $58.49 — about $815 million — and the pace accelerated into the renewal, with 6.3 million shares bought in the third quarter alone.

The business funding it is humming: second-quarter earnings of $456 million even after a one-time charge on the Anadarko sale, full-year production guidance raised, and a quarterly report management called “industry-leading performance across the board.” The price tag is the quiet part: about 8 times next year’s expected earnings. The S&P 500: about 21. There’s a 2% dividend while you hold it, and the 27 covering analysts rate it a Buy with an average target near $77 — about 25% above tonight’s price.

The honest risks? This is a commodity business wearing a nice suit — the autopilot’s fuel is oil and gas prices, and both are inflated by a war right now. Crude spiked back above $92 this week on the heaviest tanker attacks of the conflict; a genuine de-escalation (or the G7’s 100-million-barrel reserve release doing its job) deflates the cash flow that feeds the machine. The Montney is mostly natural gas, which remains stubbornly cheap. You’re also not early: the stock is up roughly 73% from its 52-week low and sits within about 9% of its high. And an allowance isn’t a command — Ovintiv used about 62% of last year’s maximum. That 62% was still $815 million of actual purchases, which is the point.

Valvoline Inc. (VVV) — Recent Price: $30.73

Breakdown: Valvoline isn’t a motor-oil company anymore — it sold that business to Saudi Aramco in 2023 for $2.65 billion. What’s left is the drive-through service chain: 2,456 quick-lube stores (about half company-run, half franchised) changing oil in fifteen minutes while you stay in the car. It’s a royalty on a simple American fact: the average vehicle on U.S. roads is the oldest on record — roughly 12.8 years — and the older the car, the more it visits.

After the Aramco sale, Valvoline poured the proceeds into its own shares and cut the share count from roughly 180 million to about 128 million — nearly 30% of the company retired in about three years. Then, last fall, it bought rival chain Breeze Autocare for $593 million, and the machine was deliberately switched off: zero buybacks in the first nine months of this fiscal year, every spare dollar pointed at the acquisition debt instead, including a voluntary $50 million loan prepayment.

Now the switch is being flipped back. CEO Lori Flees, announcing the expanded authorization: the company is making “progress toward our target leverage range” and expects to resume repurchases “following the release of our fiscal year results” — due mid-November. Meanwhile the stores keep compounding: last quarter’s revenue rose 24%, same-store sales grew 8%, adjusted earnings per share jumped 21%, and management raised full-year guidance. At about 17 times this year’s guided earnings — against the S&P’s 21 — the 15 covering analysts rate it a Buy with an average target of $43, roughly 40% above tonight’s price.

The honest risks? A promised restart is still a promise — nothing has been bought yet, and the resumption waits on the November report. The balance sheet is the reason: $1.6 billion of debt against $84 million of cash, call it 2.7 times this year’s expected cash profits, so deleveraging still competes with the buyback for every dollar. The screen price looks scarier than it is — a trailing P/E near 39 — but that’s deal and divestiture charges talking; the guided number is the run rate. And the crowd has been trimming into the print: Citi cut its target to $34 this month and Barclays to $39, even as both the average target and the growth numbers stayed far above the stock. If the November restart arrives on schedule, you’ll have been paid to sit through the argument.

American Outdoor Brands, Inc. (AOUT) — Recent Price: $16.26

Breakdown: American Outdoor Brands is the smallest name of the night: a $205 million company, spun off from Smith & Wesson in 2020, that designs gear for the campsite, the boat, and the range — BUBBA fillet knives, Caldwell shooting rests, Lockdown safes, Schrade and Old Timer blades. Sixteen brands, sold through the big outdoor retailers.

Under the $10 million program this one replaces, it bought exactly 236,907 shares, about $1.9 million worth. A tenth of the allowance — the kind of follow-through we usually scold. But look at the price on the receipts: an average of $8.15 a share, paid when the stock was scraping along near its 52-week low of $6.26. Tonight the stock is $16.26. The only checks this board wrote have doubled. It didn’t buy much. It bought then.

$33.3 million of cash and zero debt — the new program is covered three times over by cash alone. CEO Brian Murphy: the authorization “reflects the board’s continued confidence in our strategy,” and the “strong, debt-free balance sheet gives us flexibility” to invest, acquire, and repurchase. The business just turned: last quarter’s sales rose 25% as reported — with gross margins up more than six points, a swing to positive adjusted earnings, and cash-profit guidance for the year raised. The stock jumped 34% on that report.

The honest risks? The program is the smallest percentage we’ve featured, and its predecessor went 81% unspent — this board hunts markdowns, which cuts both ways: with the stock near its 52-week high after that earnings pop, the sniper may simply not fire at these prices. Only two analysts cover it, and their average target sits at $16.50 — essentially tonight’s price. The company still lost money on a reported basis last quarter, a $200-million-revenue business lives and dies with the squeezed consumer we track every week, and tariffs run straight through an imported-goods cost line. Size it like what it is: a clean balance sheet, a loaded envelope, and a board that has told you — in receipts, not words — it only spends at the bottom.

— The Daily Wall Street Alerts Team

This newsletter is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Always conduct your own due diligence before making any investment decisions.